Description
🌶 ARRABBIATA
🫒 PUTTANESCA
🥥 ALLA VODKA
✓ PICK ANY 3
✓ FREE SHIPPING
Four Italian Traditions. Pick Any Three. One Easy Decision.
How It Started with Mila & Harry.
Harry wanted to sell one sauce and do it perfectly. Mila said that was a beautiful idea and completely wrong. “The whole point,” she said, “is that different nights call for different moods. You wouldn’t wear the same thing every day. You shouldn’t cook the same sauce either.”
Harry, to his credit, came around. “Start with three of the four,” he said eventually. “Find out which ones you are. Then stock up on those. But you have to taste them properly first or you’ll never know.”
The Marry Me Sauce Sampler 3-Pack is what they agreed on. Pick any three of our four signature Italian sauces — one jar of each. Three Italian traditions. One box. Free shipping. $38.00. Nothing Says Have Me Like Marry Me — and this is where you start.
What’s in the Sampler – Pick 3
Pick any 3 of these 4 signature Italian sauces. Build your own variety pack.
🍅 Marry Me Marinara
24oz · The Neapolitan original. San Marzano-style tomatoes, cold-pressed EVOO, fresh garlic and basil. Clean, balanced, the benchmark.
🌶 Marry Me Arrabbiata
24oz · Rome’s angry sauce. Same San Marzano base, slow-simmered red pepper flakes. Heat that builds and rewards.
🫒 Marry Me Puttanesca
24oz · Naples’ briny masterpiece. Kalamata olives, capers, San Marzano base. Savory, complex, unforgettable.
🥥 Marry Me Alla Vodka
24oz · The dairy-free vodka pasta sauce. Coconut cream, Calabrian peppers, vodka. Silky, gentle 3/10 heat, fully vegan.
Three 24oz jars (your pick of 3) — 72oz total · All natural · Vegan · Gluten-free · No added sugar · Free shipping always
The Premium Foundation Behind Every Jar
Four sauces. One uncompromising standard. Every jar in the sampler starts with the same premium foundation — then takes a different regional Italian direction from there.
- Vine-Ripened San Marzano-Style Tomatoes — Grown in California using the San Marzano variety. Naturally sweet, low acidity, no sugar needed.
- Cold-Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil — Not seed oil, not canola, not refined. The real thing.
- Fresh Garlic & Herbs — Real aromatics, bloomed properly. Not dried powder.
- No Added Sugar — Never. The tomatoes handle it.
- No Preservatives — Just ingredients you can actually pronounce.
- Small-Batch Crafted — Made in Wilmington, NC. Not on an industrial line.
🍅 Marry Me Marinara
Neapolitan · Clean · The Original
Harry says: “If you can only taste one sauce this year, make it the Marinara. It has nowhere to hide — no heat, no brine, no additions. Just the tomatoes and what you do with them. And these tomatoes are exceptional.”
The Neapolitan original. San Marzano-style tomatoes at their purest — slow-simmered with cold-pressed EVOO, fresh garlic, and basil until the acidity mellows and the natural sweetness comes forward. No sugar to compensate for inferior tomatoes. No paste to bulk it out. This is what restaurant-quality pasta sauce actually tastes like, and it’s the reason the sampler exists: once you taste this, you understand what the Arrabbiata, Puttanesca, and Alla Vodka are building from.
Make it the centrepiece of:
| 🍝 Classic Spaghetti Marinara
The Neapolitan benchmark. Quality pasta, warm sauce, Parmigiano at the table. Twenty minutes of honest Italian cooking. |
🍗 Marry Me Chicken
The dish that makes people propose. Sear chicken thighs, finish in Marinara with cream and Parmigiano. An iconic date night dinner. |
| 🍕 Pizza Base
Spread directly on dough. The quality of your pizza base is the quality of your pizza — this makes homemade unbeatable. |
🍳 Shakshuka
Poach eggs directly in warmed Marinara. Weekend brunch that takes ten minutes and tastes like it took two hours. |
🌶 Marry Me Arrabbiata
Roman · Bold · The Angry One
Mila says: “The Marinara is what you cook when you want to be understood. The Arrabbiata is what you cook when you want to be felt. Heat, properly done, is intimacy in a different register.”
Rome’s most iconic spicy sauce — and it earns the name. Arrabbiata means angry in Italian, and the heat is the point: not the kind that overwhelms and disappears, but the kind that builds slowly through the meal and makes every bite more interesting than the last. Federico Fellini put this sauce in his films. Romans made it a cultural institution. We slow-simmer the red pepper flakes directly into the sauce so the heat integrates rather than sits on top — the difference between depth and a sharp spike.
Heat level: Medium-bold (6/10). If you enjoy red pepper flakes on pasta, this is your sauce. Not a challenge — a conversation.
Make it the centrepiece of:
| 🍝 Penne all’Arrabbiata
The Roman classic. Penne’s tube shape traps sauce inside and out. Finish with fresh parsley and pecorino — tradition demands it. |
🍕 Spicy Pizza Base
A heat foundation under prosciutto and mozzarella. The upgrade that makes restaurant pizza feel pedestrian by comparison. |
| 🥚 Spicy Shakshuka
The heat and the egg yolk are made for each other. Sunday brunch that wakes you up better than coffee. |
🍗 Spicy Chicken Parmesan
Swap your standard marinara for Arrabbiata and the whole dish changes character. A sauce that bites back. |
🫒 Marry Me Puttanesca
Neapolitan · Briny · The Complex One
Mila says: “Puttanesca is for the person who already knows who they are. It doesn’t ask for your approval. The Kalamata olives, the capers — they arrive with a fully formed personality and they’re not changing it for you. I respect that enormously.”
Naples’ most notorious sauce, and arguably its most complex. In Naples they call it aulive e chiapparielle — olives and capers — which tells you exactly what it is: a sauce defined by the brine and umami depth of those two ingredients layered into the same San Marzano base as the Marinara. The original Neapolitan puttanesca contains no anchovies — that’s the Roman adaptation — making ours naturally vegan and authentically Neapolitan. Bold, savory, deeply layered. The one that surprises people the most.
Want the Roman anchovy version? Before adding to the pan, dissolve 2–3 anchovy fillets in warm olive oil over low heat — 60 seconds, they disappear entirely. Add Marry Me Puttanesca directly on top. Deep umami richness, no fishiness. Outstanding.
Make it the centrepiece of:
| 🍝 Spaghetti alla Puttanesca
The Neapolitan classic. Long noodles tangle with olives and capers. Fresh parsley. No parmesan — the capers handle the salt. |
🐟 Baked Cod in Puttanesca
The olive-caper brine amplifies white fish rather than competing with it. Mediterranean simplicity. Restaurant result. |
| 🥩 Braised Chicken Thighs
Low and slow in Puttanesca — the olives and capers break down into a deeply flavoured pan sauce that requires almost no effort. |
🫒 Stuffed Peppers
The olive-caper combination transforms the filling into something genuinely Mediterranean. A dish with real character. |
🥥 Marry Me Alla Vodka
Modern Italian · Silky · The Dairy-Free Reinvention
Harry says: “Penne alla vodka is the dish that converted me to Italian-American cooking. Then we made it dairy-free and I had to rebuild my whole worldview. Coconut cream is every bit as silky as heavy cream. I will die on this hill.”
The richest pasta sauce in Italian-American cooking, completely reimagined. Traditional alla vodka relies on heavy cream for its signature silkiness — we use coconut cream instead, and the result is every bit as luxurious. Same depth. Same velvety texture. Zero dairy. The vodka itself does the work most people don’t know about: it’s a solvent that unlocks aromatic compounds in tomatoes that water and oil can’t reach. The alcohol evaporates completely during cooking. What’s left is a deeper, more complex tomato flavor that’s impossible to achieve without it. Add gentle warmth from Calabrian peppers and you have a sauce that tastes like it took hours.
Heat level: Gentle (3/10). The Calabrian peppers add fruity warmth, not raw heat. Most people who avoid spicy food find this perfectly approachable.
Make it the centrepiece of:
| 🍝 Penne alla Vodka
The classic. Toss with al dente penne, splash of pasta water, fresh basil and black pepper. Restaurant quality in 15 minutes. |
🍝 Vodka Rigatoni
Rigatoni’s ridges and tubes hold this sauce perfectly. Equally traditional, equally delicious. Date night with zero compromise. |
| 🍕 Vodka Sauce Pizza
Spread on dough for a pizza that beats any restaurant version. Fresh mozzarella and basil complete it. Game-changer. |
🍗 Braised Chicken Thighs
Simmer chicken thighs, Italian sausage, or meatballs in the sauce. The vodka base adds depth no plain marinara can match. |
Why $38.00 Is the Easiest Decision You’ll Make Today
|
72oz Total Three 24oz jars — enough for 6–9 complete Italian dinners for two. |
Free Shipping Always. No minimum threshold — the sampler includes it automatically. |
|
Pick Any 3 of 4 Build your own variety pack. Three completely different Italian evenings, your choice. |
vs Restaurant One restaurant pasta for two costs more than this entire sampler. Privacy included here. |
“The sampler exists for exactly one reason: you shouldn’t have to choose before you know. Taste three. Then you’ll know.” — Harry Tackle
The Sampler That Gives the Gift of Discovery
Mila’s take on giving the Sampler as a gift: “You are not giving someone three jars of sauce. You are giving them three evenings in Italy — the regions of their choosing. You are giving them a culinary education in the most pleasurable format imaginable. That is a thoughtful gift.”
Harry’s version: “It’s the gift for people who already cook. Or for people who want to start. Or for couples who want a reason to be in the kitchen together on three different nights. It covers every case.”
|
🍝 Italian Food Lovers People who have opinions about pasta shapes will immediately understand the quality difference. This is the gift at their level. |
💑 Couples Who Cook Together Three sauces is three date nights. The best evenings at home are built in the kitchen. Give them the ingredients. |
|
🏠 Housewarming Gifts Stock someone’s new kitchen with the Italian pantry they’ll actually be excited to use. Practical and genuinely exceptional. |
🎁 Anyone Who Has Everything They have the plates. They have the kitchen. They don’t have these sauces. Now they do. |
Three Jars. Three Meals Donated.
For every jar sold, we donate one meal to tukr box®
The Sampler means three donations. Great food should nourish communities, not just individuals.
All Natural. Nothing Hidden. Nothing to Hide.
All four sauces carry the same clean label — and it’s short enough to read in under ten seconds. No industrial seed oils. No tomato paste or concentrate bulking out cheap tomatoes. No added sugar compensating for those cheap tomatoes. No preservatives extending shelf life at the expense of flavour.
- All four sauces are: Vegan · Gluten-Free · Dairy-Free · No Added Sugar · No Preservatives
- Marinara & Arrabbiata ingredients: San Marzano-Style Tomatoes, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Garlic, Basil, Onion, Sea Salt, Black Pepper (Arrabbiata adds: Red Pepper Flakes)
- Puttanesca ingredients: San Marzano-Style Tomatoes, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Kalamata Black Olives, Capers, Garlic, Oregano, Basil, Sea Salt, Black Pepper, Chilli Flakes
- Alla Vodka ingredients: Plum Tomatoes, Fresh Onions, Tomato Paste, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Garlic, Coconut Cream, Carrots, Apple Juice, Calabrian Peppers, Spices, Vodka, Salt, Citric Acid
- Shelf Life: 18+ months unopened · Refrigerate after opening · Use within 7–10 days
- Made In: Wilmington, North Carolina, USA · Small-batch artisan crafted
- Shipping: Free — always on this sampler
What Happens When People Taste the Sampler
|
“Ordered the sampler not knowing which ones I’d like. Two weeks later I have the Puttanesca and Alla Vodka on repeat and ordered the 3-packs of both. The Marinara converted my husband from someone who thought he didn’t like marinara.” — Christina R. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
“The sampler is the correct starting point. I expected the Marinara to win. It didn’t. The Arrabbiata is extraordinary — the heat builds exactly the way it should. Now I can’t go back to standard pasta sauce.” — Marco D. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
|
“Bought this for my partner who ‘doesn’t really like pasta sauce.’ Three evenings later he asked me to order the Puttanesca 3-pack. The sampler is a gateway drug and I have zero regrets.” — Sofia B. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
“I’m dairy-free for two years and gave up on vodka pasta. The Alla Vodka in this sampler changed everything — you cannot tell it’s coconut cream. Picked Marinara, Alla Vodka, Arrabbiata. All three winners.” — Amanda K. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
What to Read Before Your First Sampler Night
- Best Pasta Shapes for Gourmet Sauce — penne with arrabbiata, spaghetti with puttanesca, rigatoni with alla vodka, and why it matters
- Romantic Pasta Recipes for Two — date night dishes for every sauce in the sampler
- Date Night Meals — the complete guide to building an evening around Italian cooking
- Why Italian Food Is Romantic — Mila’s answer to the question everyone’s thinking
- Italian Regional Sauce Traditions — the history behind each sauce in this sampler
Frequently Asked Questions
How does the gourmet pasta sauce sampler work?
Use the bundle selector at the top of the page to pick any 3 of our 4 signature sauces — Marinara, Arrabbiata, Puttanesca, or Alla Vodka. The price stays $38.00 no matter which three you choose, with free shipping included automatically. Each slot accepts one jar of one sauce, so you’ll receive three different sauces.
Can I pick three jars of the same sauce?
No — each slot accepts one of each sauce, so you’ll always get three different sauces. If you want three jars of the same sauce, our individual 3-packs are the right choice: Marinara 3-Pack, Arrabbiata 3-Pack, Puttanesca 3-Pack, or Alla Vodka 3-Pack — all $38.00 with free shipping.
What’s the best order to taste the sauces?
Start with the Marinara if you picked it — it’s the baseline and the purest expression of the San Marzano quality. Then move to Arrabbiata for heat, Puttanesca for brine and complexity, or Alla Vodka for coconut-cream silkiness. Each builds on the same foundation in a completely different direction.
Does the sampler include free shipping?
Yes — always. Orders ship within 1–2 business days from Wilmington, NC and typically arrive in 3–7 days depending on location.
Are all four sauces vegan and gluten-free?
Yes — every Marry Me sauce is fully vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, all-natural, and made with no added sugar or preservatives. The Alla Vodka uses coconut cream instead of heavy cream. The Puttanesca follows authentic Neapolitan tradition with no anchovies. You can pick any combination knowing every option meets the same dietary standards.
Which sauces are spicy and which aren’t?
Heat levels: Marinara is 0/10 (no heat), Puttanesca is 1/10 (savory, not spicy), Alla Vodka is 3/10 (gentle Calabrian warmth), and Arrabbiata is 6/10 (bold, fiery, intentionally hot). If you’re avoiding spice entirely, pick Marinara, Puttanesca, and Alla Vodka. If you love heat, Arrabbiata is non-negotiable.
How many dinners will this cover?
Each 24oz jar serves 2–3 pasta meals for two people. The sampler — three jars — covers 6–9 complete dinners for two. Three Italian regions of your choosing, nine potential evenings. The obvious approach is one sauce per occasion to compare properly, then stock up on your favourites.
What pasta shape goes with each sauce?
Marinara: spaghetti or rigatoni. Arrabbiata: penne (the traditional Roman shape — the tubes trap the sauce inside and outside). Puttanesca: spaghetti or linguine — the long noodles tangle with the olives and capers. Alla Vodka: penne or rigatoni — the cream-based sauce clings to ridged shapes. See our full pasta shapes guide for the complete breakdown.
Is this a good gift?
It’s one of our best. Three sauces at this quality level, shipped free, in one box — for $38.00. Works for Italian food lovers, couples, home cooks, housewarmings, and anyone you want to genuinely impress rather than just acknowledge. For gift baskets that include pasta, Parmigiano, and finishing ingredients, see our gourmet gift basket collection.
What is your return policy?
For food safety reasons we cannot accept returns on opened or unopened food items. If your order arrives damaged or you have a quality concern, contact us at info@marrymebrands.com and we will make it right immediately.
Nothing Says Have Me Like Marry Me.
Start Here. Find Your Sauces. Come Back for More.
Four Italian traditions. Pick any three. One small-batch standard.
$38.00. Free shipping. The obvious decision.
Choose Your 3 Sauces — $38.00 Free Shipping →
Once you find your favourites — the Marinara 3-pack · Arrabbiata 3-pack · Puttanesca 3-pack · Alla Vodka 3-pack — are ready. Or upgrade to the 4-Pack Sampler to get all four at once.
Reviews
There are no reviews yet